This is an archive of official documents related to the various constitutional challenges to the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (as amended by the Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010). These documents have been collected by Santa Clara Law Professor Bradley Joondeph, and his research assistant, Brandon Douglass. Legal analysis and commentary on these documents can be found on Professor Joondeph's blog, ACA Litigation Blog.

Follow

Amicus Briefs

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - AARP Amicus Brief, AARP

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - ACLJ Amicus, American Center for Law & Justice

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - American Association of People with Disabilities Amicus Brief, American Association of People with Disabilities

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - American Cancer Society Amicus Brief, American Cancer Society

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - American Center for Law & Justice Amicus Brief, American Center for Law & Justice

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - American Hospital Association Amicus Brief, American Hospital Association

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - American Nurses Association Amicus Brief, American Nurses Association

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - America's Health Insurance Plans Amicus Brief, America's Health Insurance Plans

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus Brief CATO Institute et al., CATO Institute

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus Brief of Landmark Legal Foundation, Landmark Legal Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus Brief of Virginia Organizing, Virginia Organizing

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus Brief of Washington Legal Foundation, Washington Legal Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus Brief of Young Invincibles, Young Invincibles

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus of American Civil Rights Union, American Civil Rights Union

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus of Americans for Free Choice in Medicine, Americans for Free Choice in Medicine

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus of Constitutional Law Professors, Gillian E. Metzger

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus of Mountain States Legal Foundation, Mountain States Legal Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Amicus of Physician Hospitals of America, Physician Hospitals of America

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Association of American Physicians and Surgeons Amicus Brief, Association of American Physicians and Surgeons

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Barry Friedman Amicus Brief, Barry Friedman

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - CATO Institute Amicus Brief, CATO Institute

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Commonwealth of Massachusetts Amicus Brief, Commonwealth of Massachusetts

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Constitutional Accountability Center Amicus Brief, Constitutional Accountability Center

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Constitutional Law Professors Amicus Brief, Jack Balkin, Gillian E. Metzger, and Trevor W. Morrison

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Economics Professors Amicus Brief, Kenneth Arrow, George Akerlof, and Eric Maskin

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Governor of Washington Amicus Brief, Christine Gregoire

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Justice and Freedom Fund Amicus Brief, Justice and Freedom Fund

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Kevin Walsh Amicus Brief, Kevin Walsh

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Landmark Legal Amicus, Landmark Legal Foundation

Virginia v. Sebelius - March of Dimes et al. Amicus, March of Dimes Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - National Women's Law Center Amicus Brief, National Women's Law Center

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Pacific Legal Foundation Amicus Brief, Pacific Legal Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Professors of Federal Jurisdiction Amicus Brief, Erwin Chemerinsky and Janet Cooper Alexander

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Service Employees International Union, Service Employees International Union

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Small Business Majority Amicus, Small Business Majority Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - State of California Amicus Brief, Attorney General Office of the State of California

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Virginia Organizing Amicus Brief, Virginia Organizing

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Washington Legal Foundation Amicus, Washington Legal Foundation

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Washington Legal Foundation Amicus Brief, Ilya Somin

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Young Invincibles Amicus Brief, Young Invincibles

Appellant Briefs

PDF

Baldwin v. Sebelius - Appellants' Reply Brief, Steve Baldwin

PDF

Baldwin v. Sebelius - Brief for Appellants, Steve Baldwin

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Brief for Appellants, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Response Brief for the States, State of Florida

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Response/Reply Brief for Appellants, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Florida v. HHS - States Reply Brief, State of Florida

PDF

Kinder v. Geithner - Brief of Appellants, Peter Kinder

PDF

Kinder v. Geithner - Reply Brief of Appellants, Timothy Geithner

PDF

Liberty University v. Geithner - Appelants' reply brief, Liberty University

PDF

Liberty University v. Geithner - Appelants' supplemental brief, Liberty University

PDF

Liberty University v. Geithner - Brief for Appellants, Liberty University

PDF

New Jersey Physicians v. President of the United States - Appellants' Brief, New Jersey Physicians

PDF

New Jersey Physicians v. President of the United States - Appellants' Reply Brief, New Jersey Physicians

PDF

Seven-Sky v. Holder - Brief of Appellants, Susan Seven-Sky

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - Appellant's Additional Citation, Thomas More Law Center

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - Appellants' Brief, Thomas More Law Center

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - Appellants' Reply Brief, Thomas More Law Center

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - Appellants' Response to Motion to Dismiss, Thomas More Law Center

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - Appellants' Supplemental Letter Brief, Thomas More Law Center

PDF

U.S. Citizens Ass'n v. Sebelius - Brief of Appellants, U.S. Citizens Association

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - U.S. Brief for Appellant, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Virginia Reply Brief, Commonwealth of Virginia

Appellee Briefs

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Brief for Private Plaintiffs, National Federation of Independent Business

PDF

Florida v. HHS - States' Reply Brief, State of Florida

PDF

Florida v. HHS - U.S. Reply Brief, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Kinder v. Geithner - Appellees Brief, Timothy Geithner

PDF

Liberty University v. Geithner - U.S. brief for appellees, Timothy Geithner

PDF

Liberty University v. Geithner - U.S. supplemental brief, Timothy Geithner

PDF

New Jersey Physicians v. President of the United States - U.S. Brief as Appellee, Barack Obama

PDF

Seven-Sky v. Holder - Brief of United States, Eric Holder

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - Brief of United States as Appellee, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Thomas More Law Center v. Obama - United States Supplemental Letter Brief, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

U.S. Citizens Ass'n v. Sebelius - Brief of United States, Kathleen Sebelius

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Appellee's Opening Brief and Response Brief, Commonwealth of Virginia

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - U.S. Reply Brief, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Virginia Supplemental Brief, Commonwealth of Virginia

Articles

PDF

The Health Care Cases and the New Meaning of Commandeering, Bradley W. Joondeph

Complaints

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - Amended Complaint (third amended petition), Phil Bryant

PDF

Calvey v. Obama - Second Amended Complaint, Kevin Calvey

PDF

Coons v. Geithner - Amended Complaint, Nick Coons

PDF

Coons v. Geithner - Original Complaint, Nick Coons

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Amended Complaint, State of Florida

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Original Complaint, State of Florida

PDF

Florida v. HHS - Second Amended Complaint, State of Florida

PDF

Goudy-Bachman v. HHS - Original Complaint, Barbara Goudy-Bachman

PDF

Kinder v. Geithner - Original Complaint, Peter Kinder

PDF

Liberty University v. Geithner - Original Complaint, Liberty University

PDF

Oklahoma v. Sebelius - Original Complaint, State of Oklahoma

PDF

Seven-Sky v. Holder - Amended Complaint, Susan Seven-Sky

PDF

Sissel v. HHS - Original Complaint, Matt Sissel

PDF

Virginia v. Sebelius - Original Complaint, Commonwealth of Virginia

Memoranda

PDF

Baldwin v. Sebelius - Brief for United States, United States Department of Health and Human Services

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - District Court Memorandum, United States District Court for the Southern District of Mississippi

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - Lieutenant Governor Bryant's Response to the U.S. Motion to Dismiss, Phil Bryant

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - Plaintiffs' Response to U.S. Motion to Dismiss, Phil Bryant

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - Plaintiffs' Response to U.S. Motion to Dismiss in Part and for Jurisdictional Purposes, Phil Bryant

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - U.S. Memorandum in Support of Motion to Dismiss, Eric Holder

PDF

Bryant v. Holder - U.S. Reply Brief, Eric Holder

PDF

Coons v. Geithner - Plaintiff's Reply Brief, Nick Coons

PDF

Coons v. Geithner - Plaintiff's Reply to U.S. Motion to stay Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgement, Nick Coons